After years of speculation, the UK’s complex property tax is getting a much-needed facelift. Could a new mansion tax prevent the brewing financial crisis, or will it hurt the economy?
As the United Kingdom faces stagnating economic growth and spiralling public debt interest rates, the Autumn budget is one of the most anticipated in years. At the centre of it is the need for the government to plug a £20 billion hole in public finances.
Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves is on the hot seat once again and is desperate for a miracle. Her goal is to raise as much cash as possible via the only tax reform her party will permit at the moment: property tax. While speculations are rife about how big the changes will be, many wonder if it would be enough to avert another economic disaster.
The UK’s Public Finance Disaster
With the yield on 30-year government bonds now at a record high of 5.72%, the Chancellor has been tasked with “getting a grip” on the economy. Many people, including the head of the Conservative Party, Kemi Badenoch, fear that the UK might need an IMF bailout. This would be the first time in nearly five decades that the country would need assistance from the global lender.
Given the current state of public finances, many fear that the autumn budget won’t be enough to cover the nearly £21 billion deficit for next year. To make matters worse, an independent think tank, the National Institute of Economic and Social Research (Niesr), estimates the black hole could be as much as £50 billion.
Reeves has ridiculed both the idea that the UK will need help from the IMF as well as the figure put forward by Niesr. “Working people and businesses can rest assured, I know how important it is to return growth in investments to our economy and I will do that in the Budget this year,” Reeves told the BBC.
However, the Chancellor has limited wiggle room, as her party pledged not to increase income tax, National Insurance (NI), or VAT. What isn’t off the table is property tax, and that is where Reeves could potentially raise up to £40 billion.
The only question is how and who will bear the brunt of it?
The Mansion Tax
Reeves has been publicly asking for ideas, and so far, her government and several think tanks have proposed four possible changes to the property tax system. The first, of course, is a proportional tax on the wealthy.
One way she could do this is by introducing a National Insurance tax for landlords. Currently, only full-time landlords and those with multiple properties are required to make NI contributions. However, the Resolution Foundation think tank has proposed a new arrangement. They suggested that all landlords should pay NI at a basic rate of 20%, with an extra 8% for earnings above £50,270 a year. However, this will not apply to companies that own rental properties. Resolution Foundation recommends a phased approach that will eventually raise £3 billion a year.
Another proposal is to scrap or replace the stamp duty. The current stamp duty system has been criticised by economists and politicians on both sides of the aisle. Stamp duty is “a huge barrier to movement, from first-time buyers to downsizers,” according to Colleen Babcock, Head of Partner Marketing at Rightmove.
Tim Leunig, the Chief Economics at Onward Think Tank, suggests replacing the stamp duty with a property tax. Leunig wants the government to levy a tax on house values over £500,000. He proposed a starting rate of 0.54% with a 0.278% supplement on values over £1m. Leunig argues that this will raise just as much money as the stamp duty over time.
However, scrapping the stamp duty will have an immediate negative impact. Last year, this tax generated £11.6 billion. If Reeves were to overhaul stamp duty, she would also need to introduce another reform.
Back in 2018, Reeves wrote an article campaigning for the removal of the Council Tax. “We should also consider the case for the overhaul [of the Council Tax] and replacement with a property tax, levied on property owners. It would be more equitable and it would place the burden on landlords and not tenants,” Reeves wrote. So, instead of abolishing stamp duty to introduce a property tax, she could consider shelving council tax instead.
The Labour Party has been flirting with the idea of a ‘mansion tax’ for decades, and has considered introducing a new council tax bracket for more expensive homes. According to the Institute for Fiscal Studies think-tank, increasing council tax rates on mansions by 50% will bring in an extra £3.5 billion per year. The government will then redistribute this money to local councils.
As radical as this idea might be, the most aggressive proposal has been to introduce a capital gains tax (CGT) on primary residences. Right now, CGT only applies to second homes and this tax raised £2.2 billion last year. While CGT on primary residences goes against one of Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s promises, there is a workaround.
Some proponents suggest levying this tax only on homes above £1.5 million. According to The Times, this could raise between £30 billion and £40 billion. However, critics argue that this might hinder property sales and affect the market disproportionately.
“A proposed mansion tax would only affect a small proportion of the market. However, the Government needs to be cautious over the cumulative effect of taxation on higher priced areas of the country as it simply risks stalling this part of the market,” said Johan Svanstrom, chief executive of Rightmove.
The real problem for Reeves, though, is whether these reforms will raise enough revenue by next year.
Not Radical Enough
So far, none of the property tax proposals has the potential to plug the public finance deficit. But beyond the politics, every economist agrees that the stamp duty needs to go and the council tax system is outdated.
However, is a property tax the best alternative, or does Reeves have another ace up her sleeve? We’ll find out on November 26th.















